Ask three contractors to price the same deck and you will rarely get three numbers you can compare. One includes the permit; the others don’t mention it. One lists the footing count; another gives a flat number that “may adjust” once digging starts. One prices pressure-treated lumber, another prices composite without naming the product line. Before you can decide which quote is fair, you have to make sure all three describe the same project. This guide explains how to compare deck quotes line by line, what a complete quote should include, and which payment and change-order terms deserve a second look before you sign.
Why Deck Quotes Are So Hard to Compare
A deck quote is a contractor’s written description of a project plus a number attached to it. If the descriptions differ, the numbers mean nothing side by side. The Illinois Attorney General’s home repair guidance makes the same point: get written estimates from contractors who have actually visited your home, and make sure the estimates are based on the same work so you can make a meaningful comparison.
The fastest way to do that is to build a simple checklist from the most detailed quote you receive, then ask the other contractors to fill in whatever they left out.
What Should a Deck Quote Include?
A complete deck quote should spell out:
- Materials: lumber species and grade for wood, or the brand and product line for composite. “Composite decking” alone is not a specification. If you are still deciding, our guide to wood vs. composite decking covers the trade-offs.
- Size and layout: square footage, shape, levels and height above grade.
- Structure: ledger attachment, posts, beams, joist size and spacing.
- Footings: how many, how deep, and what happens if more are needed.
- Railings and stairs: material, style, stair count and configuration.
- Permit: who applies for it and whether the fee is included or billed separately.
- Demolition and haul-away if an old deck is coming out.
- Timeline: estimated start and completion dates.
- Payment schedule and change-order process (more on both below).
- Warranty: the contractor’s labor warranty and any manufacturer product warranty.
A quote that says “deck boards and labor” without describing framing, ledger and footings is not a complete quote. If the contractor later finds the rim joist needs repair or an extra footing is required, you have nothing in writing to measure the change-order price against.
Line items that often go missing
When we compare quotes with homeowners, the gaps usually show up in the same places: permit fees, removal of the old deck, stair landings, post caps and lighting, and any repair to the house wall behind the ledger. None of these are unusual items. They are simply easy to leave off a quote that is meant to look smaller than the competition’s.
Permits: Who Applies, and Who Pays?
In Chicago, the property owner is ultimately responsible for making sure the right permits are in place, but a contractor, architect or other person you authorize can apply on your behalf. For porch and deck repair under the City’s Express Permit Program, the application lists a licensed general contractor. A new deck, or one rebuilt in a different size or location, typically needs plans prepared by a licensed design professional. Rules change, so confirm your specific project with the Chicago Department of Buildings or, in the suburbs, your village building department.
What matters for comparing quotes is that each one answers two questions in writing: who will apply for the permit, and is the permit fee included. Permit fees are set by each municipality, so check with your building department rather than relying on a figure from a quote or a website. Be cautious if a contractor who is doing the work asks you to apply as an owner-builder, or suggests skipping the permit altogether. Unpermitted work can cause problems at inspection or resale, and an insurer may question or deny a claim tied to it.
Checking License and Insurance
Illinois does not issue a statewide general contractor license for residential work, so licensing is handled locally.
- City of Chicago: According to the Department of Buildings, a licensed and insured general contractor is required for most building construction, rehabilitation and demolition work in the city. License classes are tied to project value. There is a limited exception for owner-occupants acting as their own general contractor on qualifying homes. Ask for the contractor’s Chicago general contractor license number and check it against the City’s list of licensed contractors.
- Suburbs: Each municipality sets its own rules. Many require contractors to register or hold a license with the village, and unincorporated Cook County has its own contractor registration. Your village hall can tell you what applies.
For insurance, the Illinois Home Repair and Remodeling Act requires contractors it covers to carry liability and property damage insurance. The Attorney General also advises confirming that your contractor carries workers’ compensation for employees and subcontractors. Ask for a current certificate of insurance and confirm with the insurance company that the policy is active. Coverage limits vary by contractor, so compare them across quotes the same way you compare materials.
Deposits and Payment Schedules
The Illinois Attorney General’s guide, Home Repair and Construction: What You Should Know, lists a request to pay for the entire job up front as a warning sign. Its advice on payment is straightforward:
- Negotiate a payment schedule based on completion of specific stages of the job.
- Keep the down payment as small as you can negotiate.
- Consider an independent escrow agent, such as a bank or title company, for larger projects.
- Do not make the final payment until you are satisfied with the work and have signed lien waivers showing subcontractors and suppliers have been paid.
Many deck contractors ask for a modest deposit at signing to order materials, with the rest tied to progress. A stage-based schedule for a new deck often looks like this:
- Deposit at contract signing.
- Payment after footings and framing are complete (and any required inspection has passed).
- Payment after decking, railings and stairs are installed.
- Final payment after the final inspection passes, punch-list items are finished and lien waivers are delivered.
Holding the final payment until the final inspection and punch list are done gives you real leverage to get the last details finished. If one quote asks for far more money before work starts than the others do, ask why, and get the answer in writing.
What Illinois law requires in the contract
Under the Illinois Home Repair and Remodeling Act, home repair or remodeling work over $1,000 requires a written contract or work order that states the total cost, including parts, materials and any charge for the estimate. Before signing a contract over $1,000, the contractor must give you the “Home Repair: Know Your Consumer Rights” pamphlet and have you sign an acknowledgment. If the contract is sold and signed at your home, you also have three business days to cancel. A quote that cannot become a contract meeting these basics is not ready to sign.
Change Orders: Read This Section Twice
A change order is a written amendment to the contract when the scope changes: an extra footing found during digging, rot in the rim joist behind the ledger, or a railing upgrade you decide on halfway through. Change orders are common on deck projects, especially replacements. The Attorney General’s checklist includes “a description of how change orders will be handled” as something every contract should contain.
Change-order language worth asking for:
- Every change order is written and signed by both parties before the changed work begins.
- Each change order states a fixed amount, not an open-ended estimate.
- Each change order shows the original contract price and the running total of all changes.
- If the quote anticipates likely extras, such as additional footings, it states how they will be priced.
Change-order language to push back on:
- “Additional work will be billed at time and materials” with no cap or estimate.
- “Contractor may proceed with additional necessary work and bill at completion.”
- Verbal approvals that get written up and signed after the work is already done.
Why the Final Invoice Can Differ From the Quote
On the replacement projects we inspect, most surprises come from three places: the condition of the ledger and rim joist (hidden until the old deck comes off), the number and condition of footings (not always known until digging starts), and specification changes the homeowner makes during the build.
A contractor who probes the rim joist, checks existing footings and walks the grade before quoting will run into fewer surprises than one who priced the job from photos or a phone call. If a contractor won’t inspect the site before giving you a number, treat that number as an opening offer rather than a quote they intend to stand behind. Our article on how long it takes to build a deck explains where these discoveries tend to show up in the schedule.
Questions to Ask Before You Sign
- Who is applying for the permit, and is the fee included?
- What is the footing plan, and how are extra footings priced?
- Did you inspect the ledger and rim joist, and what happens if they need repair?
- What labor warranty do you offer, in writing? Manufacturer product warranties are separate. Core Improve’s warranty page shows the kind of detail to look for.
- How are change orders written, priced and approved?
- What has to be finished before the final payment is due?
For a broader hiring checklist, see what to know before hiring a deck builder.
FAQ: Comparing Deck Quotes
What affects the cost of a new deck?
Deck size and height, material choice, the number of footings, stair and railing details, the condition of the house wall where the ledger attaches, removal of an old deck, site access and permit requirements all change the price. Because these vary so much from one yard to the next, the only reliable number comes from an on-site inspection. Core Improve provides free on-site estimates.
How much should I pay up front for a deck?
The Illinois Attorney General advises keeping the down payment as small as you can negotiate, tying later payments to completed stages, and being wary of any contractor who wants the entire job paid up front. Hold the final payment until the work is complete and lien waivers are in hand.
Does a deck contractor need a license in Chicago?
For most building work in the City of Chicago, yes: the Department of Buildings requires a licensed and insured general contractor, with limited exceptions for owner-occupants acting as their own contractor. Suburbs set their own rules, so check with your village hall.
Should I just pick the lowest quote?
Not until you have confirmed every quote covers the same materials, footings, permit, railings, stairs and cleanup. The Attorney General’s guidance specifically warns against automatically choosing the lowest bidder. A low number with missing line items often becomes the highest invoice once change orders arrive.
The Bottom Line
Comparing deck quotes is mostly about making sure each one describes the same project: materials named, footings and framing spelled out, permit responsibility stated, and payment and change-order terms written down. Keep the deposit modest, tie payments to finished stages, hold the final payment until inspection and lien waivers are done, and get every change in writing before the work starts. When the paperwork is that clear, the right choice usually is too.
If you are planning a new deck or a replacement, see how we approach deck building and replacement in Chicago and the suburbs, then get a written, itemized quote after a site inspection.
Book a free on-site estimate with Core Improve
Reviewed by Roman Ivanchuk, Owner of Core Improve
Roman Ivanchuk has 20+ years of experience in deck repair, deck restoration, deck building, and exterior services across the Chicago suburbs.

